Shop All - Pantry - Condiments, Sauces & Spreads

Quick view Add to Cart

Dill Sauerkraut - 16oz

$5.99

Flanagan Farm
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Mayo with Avocado Oil - 12oz

$10.99 $8.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Peanut Butter - Crunchy - 16oz

$5.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Kimchi - Mizo Horseradish - 18oz

$8.99 $6.99

Wildbrine
Quick view Add to Cart

Olive Oil - Mediterranean EV - 16.9oz

$9.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Sauerkraut - 16oz

$5.99

Flanagan Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

Ketchup - 20oz

$2.99

Cadia
Quick view View Options

Leaf Lard- 14oz

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $14.99 - $19.99

TC Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

Peanut Butter - Creamy - 16oz

$5.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Coconut Aminos - 16.9oz

$13.49

Coconut Secret
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Unsweetened Pizza Sauce - 16oz

$7.99 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Chili Fig Spread - 9oz

$5.49

Divina
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Ranch Dressing - 8oz

$8.49 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Organic Medium Salsa - 16 oz

$4.69

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Honey Mustard Vinaigrette & Marinade - 8oz

$8.49 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

BBQ Sauce - Organic Classic - 14oz

$7.49

Triple Crown
Quick view Add to Cart

Calabrian Chili Orange Spread - 9oz

$5.99

Divina
Quick view Add to Cart

Marinara Pasta Sauce - 25oz jar

$3.49

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Apple Cider Vinegar - 32oz

$5.69

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Cranberry Sauce With Whole Berries - 14oz

$3.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Chimichurri 8oz

$9.99

TC Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

Gluten Free Dijon Mustard - 9 Oz

$5.29

Annie's Homegrown
Quick view Add to Cart

Ketchup - Sugar Free - 16oz

$6.79

Ketchup Please
Quick view Add to Cart

Strawberry Preserves - Organic - 13oz

$4.49

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Yum Yum Sauce - 10oz

$9.99 $7.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Just Fruit Spread - Organic Blueberry - 10 oz

$5.29

Crofters
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Red Beet and Cabbage Kraut - 18oz

$8.99 $6.99

Wildbrine
Quick view Add to Cart

Rice Vinegar - 8.45oz

$5.49

Madhava
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Unsweetened Cocktail Sauce - 8.5oz

$6.99 $5.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Arrabbiata Pasta Sauce - 25oz jar

$3.49

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Avocado Oil Spray - 5oz

$5.59

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

BBQ Sauce - Organic Hickory Bourbon - 14oz

$7.49

Triple Crown
Quick view Add to Cart

Jellied Cranberry Sauce - 14oz

$3.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Tartar Sauce - 7.5oz

$7.49 $6.49

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Yellow Mustard - 14oz

$2.29

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Fig Spread - 9oz

$5.49

Divina
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Frizzle High Heat Cooking Oil - 25.36Fl Oz

$14.99 $12.99

Graza
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Just Fruit Spread - Organic Strawberry - 10 oz

$5.29 $4.79

Crofters
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Original Buffalo Sauce - 8.5oz

$6.99 $5.99

Primal Kitchen
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Pickled Red Onions with Jalapenos - 20oz

$7.49 $5.99

Wildvine
Quick view Add to Cart

Almond Butter - Creamy - 16oz

$12.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view

Balsamic Vinaigrette & Marinade - 8oz

$8.49 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Brewed Soy Sauce Gold GF - 20oz

$9.99

San-J
Quick view Add to Cart

Butternut Curry Indian Simmer Sauce - 12.5oz

$5.99

Maya Kaimal
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Chicken Dippin' Sauce - 10oz

$9.99 $7.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Dijon Mustard - 8oz jar

$2.49

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Just Fruit Spread - Organic Raspberry - 10 oz

$5.29

Crofters
Quick view Add to Cart

Maple Sweet & Smoky BBQ Sauce - 15oz

$7.49

Triple Crown
Quick view Add to Cart

Salsa - Hot - 16oz

$4.69

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Whole Grain Mustard - 8oz jar

$2.49

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Aged Vinegar Balsamic - 250ml

$5.99

Madhava
Quick view Add to Cart

Almond Butter - Chunky - 16oz

$8.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Avocado Dressing Green Goddess - 8oz

$8.59 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Balsamic Vinegar of Modena - 16.9oz

$4.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Brewed Soy Sauce Platinum Low Sodium GF - 20oz

$10.99

San-J
Quick view Add to Cart

Caramelized Onion Jam - 7.6oz

$5.49

Divina
Quick view Add to Cart

Chili Crunch Oil - 5.5oz

$10.49

Momofuku
Quick view Add to Cart

Creamy Cashew Alfredo Sauce - 16oz

$8.99

Primal Kitchen
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Drizzle Refill Can - 16.3fl oz

$19.99 $15.99

Graza
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Fancy Olive Oil Mayo Squeeze Bottle - 12oz

$11.99 $10.99

Graza
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Greek Vinaigrette & Marinade - 8oz

$8.49 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Hazelnut Chocolate Butter

$18.99

TC Farm
Quick view Add to Cart

Japanese BBQ Sauce - 17oz

$7.99

Bachan's
Quick view Add to Cart

Korean BBQ Sauce - 7oz

$4.19

Kevin's Natural Foods
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Organic Poppy Seed Dressing - 10oz

$4.99 $4.29

Briannas
Quick view Add to Cart

Pit Boss Sharp & Sassy BBQ Sauce - 15oz

$7.49

Triple Crown
Quick view Add to Cart

Red Wine Vinegar - 16.9oz

$4.19

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Salsa Verde Mild - 12oz

$4.49

Somos
Sale

Quick view

Sriracha Honey Ginger Marinade - 12OZ

$4.99 $4.29

Briannas
Quick view Add to Cart

Sweet Relish - 16fl oz

$6.99

Bubbie's
Quick view Add to Cart

Tahini - 16oz

$10.19

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Wagyu Beef Tallow - 14oz

$16.99 $10.99

Cornhusker Kitchen
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Wagyu Beef Tallow Spray - 10oz

$13.99 $8.99

Cornhusker Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Air Fryer Spray Oil - 4.7oz

$10.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

All Natural Mayonnaise - 16oz

$5.99

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Antibiotic Free Chicken Fat - 14oz

$16.99 $10.99

Cornhusker Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Apple Cider Vinegar - Bulk - 1 Gal

$23.99

Bragg
Quick view Add to Cart

Apricot Preserves - 13oz

$4.49

Cadia
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Avocado Lime Dipping Sauce - 10oz

$9.99 $7.99

Primal Kitchen
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Avocado Oil Mayonnaise - 12oz

$12.99 $8.99

Sir Kensington's
Quick view Add to Cart

BBQ Sauce - Organic Black Garlic - 14oz

$7.49

Triple Crown
Quick view Add to Cart

Birria Taco Mild Simmer Sauce - 8oz

$3.99

Somos
Quick view Add to Cart

Bison Tallow - Pint

$29.50

Northstar Bison
Quick view Add to Cart

Bison Tallow Cubes - 16 oz

$29.99

Northstar Bison
Quick view Add to Cart

Blue Agave Sriracha Hot Sauce - 9.8oz

$7.99

Yellowbird Sauce
Quick view Add to Cart

Blueberry Preserves - 13oz

$4.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Brown Gravy Mix - 1oz

$2.19

Simply Organic
Quick view Add to Cart

Buffalo Ranch Dressing & Marinade - 8 oz

$7.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Butter Masala Indian Simmer Sauce - 12.5oz

$5.99

Maya Kaimal
Quick view

Caesar Dressing - 8oz

$6.69

Annie's Homegrown
Quick view Add to Cart

Canola Oil - 32oz

$6.99

Cadia
Quick view Add to Cart

Chicken Flavored Gravy Mix - .85oz

$2.19

Simply Organic
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Cilantro Lime Dressing & Marinade - 8oz

$8.49 $6.99

Primal Kitchen
Quick view Add to Cart

Cilantro Lime Sauce - 7oz

$4.19

Kevin's Natural Foods
Sale

Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Green Kraut - 18oz

$8.99 $6.99

Wildbrine
Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Habanero Hot Sauce - 9.8oz

$7.99

Yellowbird Sauce
Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Jalapeno Hot Sauce - 9.8oz

$7.99

Yellowbird Sauce
Quick view Add to Cart

Classic Serrano Hot Sauce - 9.8oz

$7.99

Yellowbird Sauce
Quick view Add to Cart

Coconut Korma Indian Simmer Sauce - 12.5oz

$5.99

Maya Kaimal
Quick view Add to Cart

Coconut Oil - Virgin & Unrefined - 14oz

$8.99

Cadia